Someone has died and you are the heir. The inheritance tax bill is large, and you know there is money in the estate to pay it, in a fund or a share portfolio, but you are not sure you will get it out of the bank in time. So you do what the rules allow: you ask for an extension (prórroga) and then you file the Spanish inheritance tax return.
Some weeks after paying, a letter arrives from the regional tax office asking for a 5% surcharge. On a tax of €224,537, that is €11,226.85.
That is what happened to an heir in a case decided by the High Court of Justice of Extremadura (Tribunal Superior de Justicia) in judgment 79/2025, of 5 March. The court annulled the surcharge.
How the extension for Spanish inheritance tax works
You have six months from the date of death to file and pay Spanish inheritance tax (article 67 of the Inheritance Tax Regulation). Article 68 of the same Regulation lets the heirs ask for an extension of another six months, on these terms:
- The request has to be made within the first five months. After that, it is not granted.
- It goes with the death certificate, the names and addresses of the heirs and their relationship to the deceased, where the assets are and their approximate value, and the reasons for asking.
- If a month passes from the request and you have not been notified of a decision, the extension is deemed granted. This is administrative silence with a positive effect (silencio administrativo positivo).
- The extension runs from the end of the first six months, and late-payment interest is charged until the day you file.
- If the extension is refused, the filing period is extended by the days that passed between your request and the notice of refusal.
What happened in the Extremadura case
The deceased died on 16 January 2018. On 13 June 2018, within the first five months, the heir asked for the extension. On 13 July 2018 he filed his inheritance tax return, without paying anything. He was still dealing with the deceased’s banks, and the tax office itself had to authorise the bank to sell the securities. The bank paid the tax on 14 September 2018, within the extended period if the extension had been granted.
The regional tax office then charged the 5% enforcement surcharge (recargo ejecutivo, article 28 of the General Tax Act) for paying after the ordinary period. Its reasoning was this:
- The heir filed on 13 July, before a full month had passed since his request. So the extension had not yet been granted by silence.
- By filing the return, he had withdrawn or given up his request for an extension.
- So the payment period ended on 16 July 2018, and from then on he was in the enforcement period.
The heir challenged the surcharge before the tax office, then before the Regional Economic-Administrative Tribunal of Extremadura, and finally before the High Court of Justice.
Does filing the tax return mean you give up the extension?
No. The court said that filing the return was neither a withdrawal of the request nor a renunciation of the extension. Under article 94 of the Common Administrative Procedure Act, a withdrawal or a renunciation can be made by any means that leaves a record of it, as long as it carries the relevant signatures:
«Tanto el desistimiento como la renuncia podrán hacerse por cualquier medio que permita su constancia, siempre que incorpore las firmas que correspondan de acuerdo con lo previsto en la normativa aplicable.»
[Unofficial translation: Both withdrawal and renunciation may be made by any means that allows them to be recorded, provided they bear the signatures required under the applicable rules.]
Nothing in what the heir filed on 13 July said that he was withdrawing his request or giving up the extension.
What the court took into account to annul the surcharge
The court looked at the circumstances of the case:
- The return was filed on the last day of the month. The court found it made no sense that filing a few days later would have kept the extension, while filing on that day lost it.
- The tax office did not refuse the extension then or afterwards.
- The tax office itself authorised later steps, such as the sale of the securities to pay the tax.
- The payment was made within a reasonable time.
- Above all, there was no express withdrawal or renunciation on record.
It also mentioned Supreme Court case law that leans towards not issuing enforcement orders or surcharges while a request for deferral is still pending, while noting that it did not strictly apply to this case.
The surcharge was annulled and the authorities were ordered to pay the costs.
So, according to this judgment, filing Spanish inheritance tax after asking for an extension does not mean you have given it up.
If the surcharge comes after accepting the inheritance late
The extension is not the only way to end up paying a surcharge. If you accept the inheritance after the deadline, acceptance takes effect from the day of death, and the return is late. I explain how that works in Spanish inheritance tax deadline when you have not yet accepted the inheritance.
If the letter you received is about the value given to a property rather than a surcharge, see Spanish property tax reassessment.
Frequently asked questions
Can I get an extension for Spanish inheritance tax?
Yes. You can ask for six more months within the first five months after the death, under article 68 of the Regulation. Late-payment interest runs from the end of the first six months until you file.
When is the extension deemed granted?
If a month passes from your request and you have not been notified of a decision, the extension is deemed granted. If it is refused, the period is extended by the days between your request and the refusal.
If I file the return before the extension is granted, do I lose it?
According to the High Court of Justice of Extremadura, judgment 79/2025, no. Filing is not a withdrawal or renunciation, which must be recorded and signed under article 94 of the Administrative Procedure Act.
What is the 5% surcharge on Spanish inheritance tax?
It is the enforcement surcharge in article 28 of the General Tax Act. It applies when tax not paid in the voluntary period is paid in full before the enforcement order is notified.
Can a surcharge be challenged?
Yes. In the Extremadura case the heir appealed to the tax office, then to the Regional Economic-Administrative Tribunal, and then to the High Court of Justice, which annulled the surcharge and awarded costs.
Have a similar case? Tell me about your case
